| | | Overture
Beautiful Orchestra | | | | |
| | | So Far Away
Jessie Mueller | | | | |
| | | 1650 Broadway Medley
Beautiful Ensemble | | | | |
| | | It Might as Well Rain Until September
Jessie Mueller | | | | |
| | | Some Kind of Wonderful
Jessie Mueller, Jake Epstein, E. Clayton Cornelious, James Harkness, Douglas Lyons & Alan Wiggins | | | | |
| | | Happy Days Are Here Again
Anika Larsen | | | | |
| | | Take Good Care of My Baby
Jake Epstein & Jessie Mueller | | | | |
| | | Will You Love Me Tomorrow
Jessie Mueller | | | | |
| | | He's Sure the Boy I Love
Anika Larsen & Jarrod Spector | | | | |
| | | Will You Love Me Tomorrow
Ashley Blanchet, Alysha Deslorieux, Carly Hughes & Rashidra Scott | | | | |
| | | Up on the Roof
E. Clayton Cornelious, James Harkness, Douglas Lyons & Alan Wiggins | | | | |
| | | On Broadway
E. Clayton Cornelious, James Harkness, Douglas Lyons & Alan Wiggins | | | | |
| | | The Locomotion
Ashley Blanchet & Beautiful Ensemble | | | | |
| | | You've Lost That Lovin' Feeling
Jarrod Spector, Josh Davis, Kevin Duda & Beautiful Ensemble | | | | |
| | | One Fine Day
Rashidra Scott, Ashley Blanchet, Alysha Deslorieux, Carly Hughes & Jessie Mueller | | | | |
| | | Chains
Jessie Mueller & Beautiful Ensemble | | | | |
| | | Walking in the Rain
Anika Larsen | | | | |
| | | Pleasant Valley Sunday
Sara King, Jake Epstein & Beautiful Ensemble | | | | |
| | | We Gotta Get Out of This Place
Jarrod Spector | | | | |
| | | Uptown
Alysha Deslorieux, Douglas Lyons, E. Clayton Cornelious & Josh Davis | | | | |
| | | It's Too Late
Jessie Mueller, Douglas Lyons, E. Clayton Cornelious & Josh Davis | | | | |
| | | You've Got a Friend
Jessie Mueller, Jarrod Spector, Anika Larsen & Jeb Brown | | | | |
| | | (You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman
Jessie Mueller & Beautiful Female Ensemble | | | | |
| | | Beautiful
Jessie Mueller & Beautiful Ensemble | | | | |
| | | I Feel the Earth Move
Jessie Mueller & Beautiful Company | | | | |
